Toxic Gas Monitoring: Cross-Sensitivity or Cross-Interference

by Dan Maxwell on May 5, 2022, 10:33:11 AM

Industrial toxic gas detection sensor used to monitor hazardous gases in a facility

Toxic Gas Monitoring: Cross-Sensitivity or Cross-Interference
4:37

In the field of toxic gas monitoring systems (TGMS), an important consideration is how conditions other than the presence of the intended target gas might affect detection. Gas detection technology is designed to identify specific chemical compounds in a monitored sample.

However, few detection technologies are so selective that they are unaffected by other chemicals that may be present. Depending on whether you take a glass-half-full or glass-half-empty perspective, this can be viewed as cross-sensitivity or cross-interference.

Examples of Cross-Sensitivity

When an application requires monitoring multiple gases in a specific location, cross-sensitivity can sometimes reduce the number of gas detection points needed.

A broad example is LEL (lower explosive limit) gas detection, which is used for various flammable gases, such as hydrogen and methane. A more selective example involves using a single gas detection point to monitor the exhaust of a two-cylinder gas cabinet containing gases from the same family, such as BCl3 and HCl.

Understanding gas detection sensor responses is an important part of TGMS design. Manufacturers provide data showing how a particular sensor is expected to respond to different gases. This information is important when evaluating appropriate alarm setpoints for both gases. 

Gas detection is often divided into two categories: ambient monitoring and exhaust monitoring. However, both types of monitoring points can be influenced by compounds not specifically expected in the sample.

Gas cabinets require substantial exhaust airflow for safe operation. As a result, they may draw in air from outside the gas enclosure, introducing additional compounds into the monitored sample.

Cross-Interference Issues

Cross-interference should be considered in all hazardous gas monitoring applications. Manufacturer data should identify which gas exposures may increase or decrease a sensor's expected response to its target gas.

For example, could exposing a sensor designed to detect gas “A” to gas “B” cause it to overreport or underreport the concentration of gas “A”?

While overreporting can lead to nuisance alarms, underreporting can have potentially dangerous consequences.

Potential Sources of Cross-Sensitivity or Cross-Interference Gases

One of the more challenging aspects of identifying potential cross-sensitivity or cross-interference is accounting for gases and chemicals present in the surrounding environment.

Common sources include:

    • Construction site activities
    • Emergency generators
    • Vehicle exhaust
      • Nitrogen oxides (NOx)
      • Sulfur oxides (SOx)
      • Carbon monoxide (CO)
    • Air pollution and smog
      • Ozone (O3)
      • Carbon dioxide (CO2)
      • Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)
    • Cleaning chemicals

Cleaning chemicals are a common source of interference. Isopropyl alcohol (IPA), for example, is widely used in microelectronics manufacturing facilities where TGMS monitors other hazardous gases. IPA can cause certain gas sensors to alarm.

Ultimately, whether viewed as cross-sensitivity or cross-interference, understanding these potential influences is an important part of TGMS design and facility operation.

After reading this blog, a colleague contacted me to share an unusual cross-sensitivity experience. At one facility, a large indoor gathering space is located near the gas storage rooms. The space is frequently used for celebrations where alcoholic beverages are consumed and occasionally spilled.

During these events, gas detection technologies in the nearby storage rooms that are sensitive to IPA have been known to trigger alarms.

For more information about toxic gas monitoring technologies, contact Dan directly at dmaxwell@hallam-ics.com or reach out through our TGMS Help Desk.

About the Author

Dan Maxwell is a Senior Project Manager with Hallam-ICS's Toxic Gas Monitoring Systems (TGMS) team. With a background in mechanical engineering and project management in the construction and manufacturing industries, Dan joined Hallam-ICS in 1999. Throughout his career, he has worked on projects for advanced technology clients, developing lasting professional relationships and a practical understanding of the challenges involved in complex technical environments.

Read  My Hallam Story  

About Hallam-ICS

Hallam-ICS is an engineering and automation company that designs MEP systems for facilities and plants, engineers control and automation solutions, and ensures safety and regulatory compliance through arc flash studies, commissioning, and validation. Our offices are located in Massachusetts, Connecticut, New York, Vermont, North Carolina, Texas and California and our projects take us world-wide. 

Contact Us

Subscribe to the Hallam-ICS Blog

No Comments Yet

Let us know what you think